scriptwriting

I've been looking at how your skill handles narrative structure—there's some solid thinking around pacing, but the execution patterns suggest a few fundamental gaps in how it guides users through the writing process. Let me walk you through what's working and where we need to shore things up.

Links:

• GitHub
• Your agentic skill in the SkillzWave marketplace

The TL;DR

You're at 55/100, which puts you in F territory. This is based on Anthropic's 5-pillar rubric for evaluating agentic skills. Your strongest area is Spec Compliance (12/15)—the technical setup is solid. But Progressive Disclosure Architecture (12/30) and Ease of Use (13/25) are dragging the score down significantly. The skill exists, but it's not yet guiding users effectively.

What's Working Well

• Clean spec foundation – Your frontmatter is valid, naming follows conventions (hyphen-case), and the core structure is sound
• Real problem space – You're addressing an actual gap in video script creation, not solving a problem nobody has
• 5-part framework – Hook, Problem, Solution, Proof, CTA is a legitimate structure that gives users something concrete to work with
• Tips section – The tone advice ("write for the ear") and time constraints are useful guardrails

The Big One: Missing Reference Architecture

Your biggest blocker is that templates and examples are described but never actually provided. You mention "script template with columns for VO/dialogue, visuals... storyboard grid" but they don't exist anywhere. This tanks your Progressive Disclosure Architecture score because:

1. A skill with no layered references (references/ directory) maxes out at 4/30 on PDA
2. Users have to mentally construct the template while reading about it
3. You lose the token-effici...