student-success-scorecard

I noticed you're tackling the tricky problem of measuring student success across different contexts—that's a domain where one-size-fits-all metrics usually fail. Your approach here comes in at 60/100, which puts you in D territory. The foundation is solid, but there's meaningful room to strengthen the implementation and documentation to help other developers actually use this effectively.

Links:

• GitHub
• SkillzWave Marketplace

The TL;DR

You're at 60/100, with your strongest pillar being Spec Compliance (11/15) and your biggest weakness in Utility (10/20). The YAML frontmatter is clean and validation is solid, but the skill reads more like a conceptual framework than an actionable tool. You've got the right problem space—tracking student KPIs, cohorts, interventions—but the implementation guidance is too high-level to actually guide someone through building this out.

What's Working Well

• Valid spec structure — Your YAML frontmatter is properly formatted with all required fields
• Consistent terminology — KPIs, metrics, cohorts, segmentation language stays tight throughout
• Real problem domain — Student success measurement is a genuine need in edtech, not theoretical fluff
• Logical framework progression — The four-part approach (metric stack → segmentation → risk tracking → intervention) makes intuitive sense

The Big One: Missing Reference Files & Templates

Here's what's holding you back the most: You mention templates but don't provide them. Your Templates section lists "scorecard dashboard layout," "risk heatmap template," and "intervention log sheet," but they don't exist as actual files in references/.

This violates the layered architecture principle that keeps skills maintainable and reusable...