value-messaging

I dove into your value-messaging skill and found the messaging strategy is solid, but the execution feels like it's working against itself—clear examples would help developers actually use what you've built instead of just understanding it.

Links:

• GitHub
• Your agentic skill in the SkillzWave marketplace

TL;DR

You're at 65/100, which puts you in D territory. This is based on Anthropic's best practices for skill architecture. Your strongest area is Spec Compliance (11/15)—the YAML frontmatter is clean and you've got the naming conventions right. But you're getting hit hard on Utility (12/20) and Progressive Disclosure Architecture (18/30)—the framework concept is there, but it lacks the depth and examples developers need to actually execute it.

What's Working Well

• Clean spec compliance – Your frontmatter is valid, naming follows conventions, and the structure is technically sound
• Clear conceptual framework – The 5-step approach (Tier Overview → Value Pillars → Proof Points → Objection Handling → Upsell Triggers) makes logical sense for a GTM problem
• Professional tone – No marketing fluff; you're staying instructional and objective throughout

The Big One: Missing Reference Files & Examples

Here's what's killing your score: You mention templates and examples but don't provide them. You say "Tier one-pager (audience, benefits, proof, CTA)" exists, but it's just listed as a bullet point. This breaks the Progressive Disclosure Architecture pattern—you need actual reference files.

What you should do: Create a references/ directory with concrete files:

• references/tier-one-pager-template.md – actual template with fields to fill in
• references/objection-response-table.md – sample objection-handling table
• `references/...