playwright

I took a look at your playwright skill and wanted to share some thoughts.

Links:

• GitHub
• Your agentic skill in the SkillzWave marketplace

The TL;DR

You're at 83/100, solid B-grade territory. This is based on Anthropic's skill best practices rubric across five pillars. Your strongest area is Spec Compliance (14/15) — the metadata and frontmatter are dialed in. The gap is in Progressive Disclosure Architecture (22/30) — your examples are comprehensive but eating up a lot of tokens without proportional value.

What's Working Well

• Excellent discovery. Your 35+ trigger patterns are comprehensive — catching "playwrite" and "plawright" misspellings shows you thought about how people actually search. That metadata work paid off.

• Real-world problem solving. The Page Object pattern, auth persistence guidance, and locator priority strategy address actual pain points developers hit with Playwright. This isn't theoretical.

• Solid examples. Both the todo and base page examples are complete and immediately usable — they show input, output, and reasoning. That's the right approach.

The Big One: Token-Heavy Examples

Your two examples clock in at ~200 lines combined. The todo example alone is 130+ lines when you could demonstrate the Page Object pattern in 50 lines and move the full reference to references/todo-example.md if someone needs it.

Why it matters: Progressive disclosure means giving users what they need upfront without forcing them through exhaustive code blocks. Long examples are harder to parse, consume more tokens, and make the skill slower to activate.

Concrete fix: Trim the todo example to show 3-4 key methods (like navigateTo(), getTodoItem(), addTodo()) with just enough code to show the pattern. Move the full 9-method version to a reference file. This should +2 points to your PDA score.

Other Things Worth Fixing

1. Missing table of contents. At 487 lines, the XML tags alone don't cut it for navigation. Add a TOC listing the sections (mcp_first, quick_start, locator_priority, etc.) so users can jump around. Medium effort, +1 point.

2. Second-person creeping in. Lines 48-74 have imperatives like "Always fetch Playwright documentation" — drop the implied "you" and just make it active voice: "Fetch Playwright documentation before implementation." Minor polish, better consistency.

3. Workflow steps unlabeled. Your examples show final outputs but not numbered steps to get there. Add a quick "1. Create base.page.ts, 2. Create todo.page.ts..." sequence in each example for clarity. +1 point.

Quick Wins

• Add TOC → +1 point (navigation signals)
• Trim examples → +2 points (token economy)
• Label workflow steps → +1 point (ease of use)
• Fix voice consistency → +0.5 point (writing style)

These four changes get you to 87-88/100, solidly into A territory.

Checkout your skill here: SkillzWave.ai | SpillWave We have an agentic skill installer that install skills in 14+ coding agent platforms. Check out this guide on how to improve your agentic skills.