ms365-tenant-manager

I found your ms365-tenant-manager skill while reviewing the latest grading batch—the approach to tenant lifecycle management caught my attention, though the current implementation leaves some room for refinement. At 72/100, there are some solid foundations here, but I wanted to dig into what's working and where we can push it further.

Links:

• GitHub
• Your agentic skill in the SkillzWave marketplace

The TL;DR

You're at 72/100, solidly in C territory. This is based on Anthropic's best practices for agentic skills. Your Ease of Use scored the strongest at 19/25—the metadata and overall structure make sense—but Progressive Disclosure Architecture (18/30) and Utility (14/20) are dragging things down. The gap between what you promise and what you actually deliver is the core issue here.

What's Working Well

• Structure and organization – Your section headers flow logically, and the 197-line skill doesn't feel scattered. The "How to Use" section and trigger scenarios are clearly laid out.
• Realistic use cases – You nailed the practical scenarios: tenant setup, user management, security policies. These are real admin problems, not theoretical fluff.
• Security awareness – You're thinking about guards, validation steps, and rollback procedures upfront. That mindset is solid, even if the execution is incomplete.

The Big One: Missing Reference Files and Examples

This is what's actually holding you back. You list five Python scripts (tenant_setup.py, user_management.py, etc.) in lines 58–64, but they don't exist. You promise "validation checklists" and "rollback procedures" in your output capabilities, but you don't provide actual templates.

For a Microsoft 365 admin skill, this is a credibility problem....