quality-manager-qmr

I found your quality manager skill while evaluating the latest batch—it's got solid bones with real domain expertise, but it's playing a bit too safe as a reference document rather than a working tool for Claude to actually do things.

Links:

• GitHub
• Your agentic skill in the SkillzWave marketplace

The TL;DR

You're at 58/100, which lands you in F territory. Based on Anthropic's skill evaluation framework, you're strongest on Spec Compliance (12/15)—the structure is technically sound—but Progressive Disclosure Architecture is dragging you down hard at 13/30. The skill reads like a governance manual when it should read like a Claude instruction set.

What's Working Well

• Valid structure: Your frontmatter is clean YAML, name follows conventions perfectly, and it's grep-friendly (+1 bonus for that)
• Real domain knowledge: You clearly understand the QMR role in regulated industries—the responsibilities breakdown is accurate and comprehensive
• Spec compliance: Basic requirements are met; no format violations or missing mandatory fields

The Big One: Progressive Disclosure Violation

Here's the thing—you've got a 210-line monolith with placeholder references. That's the opposite of progressive disclosure. The references directory contains dummy text instead of actual content, which tells Claude there's nowhere to go for detail.

The fix: Extract your longer sections (Quality Performance Monitoring, Regulatory Interface Management) into separate reference files. Keep SKILL.md to ~80 lines with just the core, then link out. Specifically:

• Move the 19-line "Quality Performance Monitoring" section (lines 169–188) to references/monitoring-kpis.md
• Move "Regulatory Interface Management" to references/regulatory-requirements.md ...